Teddy’s New Yorker Pizza

Reviews

• Jon M.

  star star star star star 19 June 2026

  I came in on a Monday at 950PM.  I ordered the #3 steak and cheese special.   It was hot and fresh and the meat was tender.   The fries were crisp and plentiful.  It was a good value for the price.
  
  I've also had the Greek salad here which is excellent.   You get alot of vegetables for around $5.  I've also tried a slice of their cheese pizza which did not impress me.  The sauce had a very "canned tomatoe soup" taste.  I will not be ordering the pizza again.
  
  Get the steak and chese or the Greek salad.   You will not be disappointed.   The prices are very competitive as well.

• Katie R.

  star star star_border star_border star_border 27 May 2026

  The people who work here are rude. I wouldn't recommend coming here. I ordered a pizza and paid for three veggies but only selected two by mistake- when I called to ask for the third veggie to be added, the store owner acted like they couldn't add it.... i won't ever order from here again.

• Mj R.

  star star star star_border star_border 26 May 2026

  Service:
  We came in hoping to use a coupon on an app called Uconnection and the deal was for a large 1 topping pizza for $7.99. Unfortunately, the staff refused to honor it because they said they had never agreed to it. They offered me a special that was the same except for $9.99. I was disappointed but didn't push the issue. Other than that, the staff was friendly. It took less than 15 minutes for them to prepare the pizza.
  
  Vegetarian:
  I ordered a cheese pizza with spinach as my 1 topping. The pizza was generally mediocre but it was hot. The sauce and cheese was tasty, but the blandness of the spinach took away from that because they had clearly just put it on there without seasoning it at all. The crust was crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside, I enjoyed it. They have plenty of toppings that vegetarians can add to their pizza but they charge by topping. They also have pasta and salad dishes.
  
  Overall:
  The food didn't quite meet my expectations and so I was disappointed. Also, restaurants usually honor coupons under similar circumstances. I had never been to this restaurant  but was drawn in by the late-night deal. I do not think their food is worth what they are charging for it. I would give it 2.5 stars and am rounding up to 3.

• Lover Jenkins ..

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 23 May 2026

  Employees trespassed onto private property to leave their advertisement trash on my front door.

• Brian N.

  star star_border star_border star_border star_border 21 May 2026

  Came in to order the philly cheese steak. I literally witnessed the  employee handle the cash register and then proceed to make my sandwich with his BARE hands. He didn't even wash his hands or put on gloves. Sorry, but no thanks. I just left without saying anything. And I am never coming back.